Wednesday, August 26, 2015

Essay: A Merciful Punishment

God the Father by Girolamo dai Libri

The story of Adam and Eve is one of the most renowned stories in world.  It is the story of the first man and woman, how they lost paradise, and how they became mortal.  Though the biblical book of Genesis tells the most known parts of their story, there are other sources that help to complete it.  Two such sources, the Legend of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg and the Forgotten Books of Eden edited by Rutherford H. Platt, add significance to the tale that may not have been quite so obvious through the book of Genesis alone.  Throughout the story there is a theme of loss.  Adam loses a wife; Adam and Eve lose Paradise in the form of the Garden of Eden; Adam commits suicide on several occasions; Adam and Eve lose their sight as night takes over the day.  What really stands out, however, is the temporariness of those losses.
Folklore often cites Lilith as the first wife of Adam.  God created her from the dust, just as he created Adam.  Unfortunately, Lilith loathed Adam and rebuked him.  Her displeasure was so great that even three angels could not force her to return to him.  Because of this, Adam lost his first wife and was alone again with no one to share in all of God’s creation.  The Lord, however, saw Adam’s need for a companion and created Eve to lessen the burden. 
                According to the book of Genesis, the first man and woman disobey God’s one command; they eat of the Tree of Knowledge.  As a result, the couple is kicked out of Eden and sentenced to mortality.  From this point on in the reading, Adam mourns this loss.  Mercifully, God promises Adam that he and his people will be readmitted into the Garden after a period of time.  Though the promise seems to do little to console Adam, the loss is lessened by the eventuality of his return. 
                Despite God’s promise, Adam’s anguish does not dissipate.  He often throws himself to the ground from great heights in attempts to repent.  Even after God tells him that the act is unnecessary and forgiveness will be his, Adam still strikes himself down.  His many deaths last only a short while, as God returns him to his living state time and time again. 
                Upon multiple reassurances, Adam and Eve return to the cave where God had bade them to live.  Whenever night fell, the darkness was so intense that they could not see.  They cried out to God, begging to know why he would punish them with blindness.  Once again, God reassured them and promised that the loss of light was only temporary.  Still, they wept and mourned the loss.  God promised them that the night and the darkness were not punishments, but part of the day that He had created, for he knew that man would disobey him.  Soon, day broke and the darkness faded.  Once again, Adam’s loss was only temporary. 

                The impermanence of loss throughout the storytelling speaks both to the mercy of God and to the temporary nature of man.  This significance within the story is nearly impossible to find through the book of Genesis alone, which focuses more heavily on the consequences of disobedience than on mercy.  With further study into the mythology, however, the theme mercy and impermanence of loss become much harder to ignore.   


No comments:

Post a Comment